Intimate Partner Battering and Its Effects
Formerly Called: Battered Woman Syndrome

Intimate Partner Battering and Its Effects

It is essential for the judge or jury to understand how people who suffer domestic violence, usually women, respond to it. Without this understanding, the determination of whether violence actually occurred, or why a person who suffered abuse acted as the person did, could hamper the ability of a judge or jury to determine whether violence actually occurred.

1980’s: ‘Battered Woman Syndrome’

Beginning in the late 1980s, in various proceedings, both criminal, civil and in child custody cases, courts began to apply scientific approaches to help explain the actions of women who had suffered violence at the hands of a husband or someone close to them. The behavior of those who suffered violence was given a name by psychologist Lenore Walker: “battered woman syndrome,” which she described in 1989 as having elements of PTSD and learned helplessness.

1990’s: Our Society and Our Legal System Matures

In 1992, Evidence Code section 1107 was enacted in California. This statute allowed expert testimony in criminal cases regarding “battered women’s syndrome, including the physical, emotional or mental effects upon the beliefs, perceptions or behavior of domestic violence.” The purpose of Evidence Code section 1107 was to dispose of the issue of whether testimony on the subject was reliable; such evidence was to be admitted when relevant.

2000’s: ‘Battered Woman Syndrome’ REPLACED BY ‘Intimate Partner Battering’

In 2005, the term “battered women’s syndrome” was replaced by the term “intimate partner battering and its effects” in Evidence Code section 1107 because the older term was confusing to juries and judges. The term was also criticized as demeaning to women for a number of reasons, including the fact that victims of domestic violence do not normally suffer from a pathological condition.

Dispelling Misconceptions About Battered Women

Intimate Partner BatteringIn response to arguments that testimony related to the effects of domestic violence on a witness should not be admitted, the California Supreme Court has noted expert testimony was relevant to a witness’s credibility because it would assist the jury “by dispelling many of the commonly held misconceptions about battered women.” It has also been used to explain the reluctance of a parent to report child molestation as well as in other cases where the subsequent behavior of a battered witness could be interpreted to cast doubt on that witness’s account of domestic violence.

Often, expert testimony is used to explain the behavior of a person attempts to minimize previously reported domestic violence or to change what happened. It is common for a number of reasons for persons who are battered, either emotionally or physically, to recant their allegations or change their stories. These witnesses may be afraid of reprisals, or worry about the economic impact of a criminal charge or how it would look to their friends and colleagues if a partner were publicly accused of committed domestic violence. Expert testimony is also used to explain the cycle of violence that is common in dysfunctional relationships.

Today, both in criminal cases and in civil contexts, including family law cases, experts are permitted to testify about domestic violence and its effects on the person who endured the violence. Having an expert to explain behaviors that could, at first, appear to undermine claims of violence, is invaluable.

Reach Out for Advice

As experienced San Diego family law attorneys, we are available to help with advice about domestic violence, and, if necessary, with action to obtain restraining orders, along with expulsion of the abuser from the home. You should not have to live in an environment in which you or your children are at risk of physical or emotional abuse.

Call Schaffer Family Law Group at (858) 509-7907 to schedule a strategy session today.

Read More About Domestic Violence

Domestic Violence and Covid-19

ONE OF THE NATION’S “BEST LAW FIRMS” U.S. WORLD REPORT AND BEST LAWYERS IN AMERICA® Named one of the nation's Best Law Firms by US World Report and Best Lawyers in America Learn More

Sarah T. Schaffer In The News

Recent Media Events

Sarah T. Schaffer Recognized in San Diego Discover Magazines With over 220,000 attorneys in California, Schaffer is one of the few, numbering 178 within San Diego, to hold the distinction of Certified Family Law Specialist.

San Diego Magazine Women of the Year Awards Colonel Sarah T. Schaffer, USMC – Camp Pendleton recognized for her Military Service as JAG Officer.

Top 50 Influential Leaders in San Diego Sarah T. Schaffer is active in the San Diego County and North County bar associations and supports the programs of Kids’ Turn San Diego, a nonprofit that helps children through family separations, and Casa Cornelia Law Center, which provides pro bono legal services to victims of human and civil rights violations.

Dividing a Business - Discover Magazines Not all businesses have marital value, especially smaller businesses whose primary value is from the efforts of one spouse.

Sarah Schaffer on the cover of Discover Magazines
Read Sarah's Latest Article In Discover Magazines OVER 50 AND DIVORCING; Four Important Things To Keep In Mind
What Happened to My Inheritance? If you inherit money during marriage, would it be considered separate property? Learn More

Family law matters are never simple By your side every step of the way

Certified Family Law Specialist CFLS Sarah Schaffer and Leslie Ryland have been certified by the State Bar of California as “Certified Family Law Specialists,” a distinction earned by family law attorneys who have “gone beyond the standard licensing requirements.” Every attorney at Schaffer Family Law Group has either earned their CFLS Certification, or is actively working towards that professional goal as a requirement of the firm and our commitment to providing our clients the most skilled and proficient attorneys in San Diego County.

Take The First Step

What You Should Know

Top 10 Mistakes In A Divorce To avoid the top five mistakes in a divorce you must take a step back, remove the emotions and treat the process similar to a business transaction. Use these tips to help you expedite the process.

Divorce Over 50 How a 'gray divorce' will impact your retirement planning, including the timing of your retirement as well as the new economic reality divorce may bring to your life.

Top 4 Things To Know if Over 50 and Divorcing Getting a divorce after the age of 50 comes with its own set of challenges, both social and economic.

Professionals, Business Owners & Divorce Solving problems with the division of marital assets. The need for privacy and not leaving written records of your 'dirty laundry' for the world to see in the permanent public record and more...

Military Divorce Sarah serves as a colonel in the Marine Corps Reserve. Military families find Sarah’s understanding of the military and issues servicemembers face enable her to provide superior counsel.

Where Should I Start?

Find answers to common questions about divorce and family law

Browse Our FAQ's

Why Choose Sarah's Team?

Experienced, aggressive, reliable family law attorneys in San Diego

What Sets SFLG Apart?

What Can I Do Today?

Schedule a strategy session with an attorney by phone, video chat, or in office

Contact Sarah Today
Our People Make The Difference

Our People Make The Difference!

Home Page Consultation

Schedule A Consultation

To schedule a consultation please use the form below or call our office between 9 am - 5 pm at (858) 509-7907.

We will not share your information with ANYONE. EVER. FOR ANY REASON.

Agreement with terms *

Schaffer Family Law Group, APC

Divorce Lawyers in San Diego Divorce Lawyers in San Marcos